Hemorrhoid Surgery - Do You Need it?
Because of the severity of hemorrhoids, or the lack of a suitable treatment from creams, prescriptions, or other remedies for curing hemorrhoids, surgery may be the only course of action for some people. Most will try different solutions to get rid of the hemorrhoids. Because of the expense and risks associated with any type of surgery, people in general will opt for hemorrhoid surgery as a last resort.
There are different types of surgery to treat hemorrhoids all with their pros and cons. Here is a list of the 5 most common surgeries/treatments performed by a physician. Three are used for external hemorrhoids and two for internal hemorrhoids.
1. Hemorrhoidectomy
2. Laser coagulation
3. Infra-red photo coagulation
4. Injection Sclerotherpy
5. Rubber Band Ligation
Lets take a look at the five procedures in a little more detail:
Hemorrhoidectomy
Surgical removal of hemorrhoids is recommended for third and fourth degree internal hemorrhoids when other treatments are unable to alleviate severe burning, itching, swelling, protrusion and overall pain. A general anaesthesia for pain is administered prior to surgery.
Incisions are made in the tissue around the hemorrhoid. The swollen vein inside the hemorrhoid is tied off to prevent bleeding, and the hemorrhoid is removed. The surgical area may be sewn closed or left open. Medicated gauze covers the wound. The operation is conducted in a surgery centre and most patients go home the same day.
There is a procedure that uses a circular stapling device to remove haemorrhoidal tissue and close the wound. No incision is made. In this procedure, the hemorrhoid is lifted and then "stapled" back into place in the anal canal. Hemorrhoidectomy is appropriate when you have:
- Very large internal hemorrhoids.
- Internal hemorrhoids that still cause symptoms after non-surgical treatment.
- Large external hemorrhoids that cause significant discomfort and make it difficult to keep the anal area clean.
- Both internal and external hemorrhoids.
- Had other treatments for hemorrhoids (such as rubber band ligation) that have failed.
|
An hemorrhoidectomy is not normally performed until the hemorrhoids reach stage 3 or 4
|
Pros:
May provide better long-term results
95% success rate of hemorrhoids reoccurring
When nothing else works
Cons:
Surgery is more costly
Greater risk of complications
More painful than other procedure
Recovery may take longer, 2-3 weeks
Laser Surgery for Treatment of Hemorrhoids
This is becoming the preferred laser surgery (versus Laser Coagulation). This process vaporizes or excises the hemorrhoid by a surgeon. The laser beam is infinitely small allowing for precision and accuracy. Generally results in a rapid healing.
Laser Coagulation involves an electric current applied to the hemorrhoid through an electrode probe. The hemorrhoid goes through a chemical reaction to stop the flow of blood to the hemorrhoid thus resulting in the shrinking of the swollen tissue.
Pros:
Less painful
Less invasive
Less expensive
Faster healing process
Usually no over night hospital stay – may be performed in doctor’s office
Cons:
Hemorrhoids may reoccur
Infra-red photo coagulation (also called coagulation therapy)
This procedure is used to treat small and medium sized hemorrhoids. Doctors recommend coagulation therapy in cases where small internal hemorrhoids continue to cause symptoms after home treatment.
It involves a device that creates an intense beam of infra-red light. The heat created by the light causes scar tissue, which cuts cutting off the blood supply to the hemorrhoid. The hemorrhoid dies, and a scar forms on the wall of the anal canal. Only one hemorrhoid can be treated at a time. Infra-red photo-coagulation is generally done in your doctors surgery.
Pros:
Small internal hemorrhoids are often successfully treated with coagulation therapy (Large hemorrhoids are more likely to be treated with rubber band ligation)
Cons:
Procedure is painful
Only one hemorrhoid can be treated at a time
Expensive
Rubber Band Ligation
One of the most common hemorrhoid surgeries is rubber band ligation. A tiny rubber band (diameter about 1/25 of an inch) is fitted onto a special gun-like device. When the trigger is pulled, the rubber band is forced onto the base of the hemorrhoid, thus cutting off the blood flow to the hemorrhoid. The hemorrhoid shrinks and within a week or so falls off. The results is a scar in the place of the hemorrhoid. Rubber band ligation works best on first and second degree hemorrhoids.
The procedure is done in a doctor's surgery. Treatment is limited to 1 to 2 hemorrhoids at a time if done in the doctor's office. Several hemorrhoids may be treated at once if the person has general anaesthesia.
Pros:
Lease expensive of all surgical procedures
Repeat treatment for recurring symptoms is rarely needed
Performed in doctor’s office
Quick Recovery
Most widely used treatment for internal hemorrhoids
Cons:
Painful
Not all doctors have the experience or equipment to do rubber band ligation
Sclerotherapy
In sclerotherapy, a chemical solution is injected around the blood vessel to shrink the hemorrhoid. This process is used to treat bleeding internal hemorrhoids where by a sclerosing or hardening solution is injected into the base of the hemorrhoids. The solution causes an inflammation reaction which scar the vein and mucosal tissue, thus collapsing the vein walls and causing the hemorrhoids to shrivel. This procedure is performed in the doctor’s surgery.
Sclerotherapy is recommended for smaller hemorrhoids, such as first degree and early second degree hemorrhoids. Doctors recommend injection sclerotherapy in cases where:
Small hemorrhoids do not improve with home treatment.
Internal hemorrhoids are too small to treat with rubber band ligation.
You have persistent bleeding from hemorrhoids.
You are older than age 70 or are in poor health and would not be a candidate for more invasive surgery.
Pros:
Inexpensive
Multiple hemorrhoids can be treated at the same time
Fast procedure
Minor pain and discomfort
Performed in doctor’s surgery
Cons:
Sclerotherapy is not a cure for hemorrhoids
Hemorrhoids often recur after injection sclerotherapy
As mentioned earlier, surgery should be the last resort to get rid of hemorrhoids. There are less riskier methods that will treat and in some cases eliminate them forever.
As always, be sure to do research to find a suitable solution that you are comfortable with, be it surgery or one of the many natural remedies available.
You can read my earlier article on an Holistic approach to treating hemorrhoids by clicking this link